Spike - Our Thinking

Peak paranoia is real. Here’s how to use it.

Written by Steve Dennis | Jun 17, 2025, 2:09:39 PM

 

Spoiler: this is pattern recognition, not panic.

That unease is the warning before the crash.

"Why is the release delayed again?" "We had to roll back the last one." "The CIO's wife couldn't check out last night."

If these sound familiar, you're not alone.

Retail IT leaders are rightly on edge. Every peak season now arrives more volatile than the last, and also more profitable, if you can handle it. We're seeing stacking pressure from:

  • New tooling shoved into legacy estates.
  • Shadow AI and ungoverned AI adoption grafted onto brittle platforms.
  • SIs pushing through replatforms with no time to validate stability.

And then there are the cautionary tales:

  • M&S's eComm downtime, including a separate incident where a Cloudflare outage took its site down alongside AllSaints and Zalando, with none of them at fault for their own code.
  • Amazon's own AI tooling triggering four high-severity retail site incidents in a single week, including a six-hour checkout blackout.
  • A global Shopify outage that took down checkout, admin, storefronts and POS at once, and exposed just how few merchants have any uptime guarantee at all.

Meanwhile, retailers keep gearing up for their biggest peak yet, armed with full-scale load testing, robust automation, QA...

Call it preparation, not paranoia.

Peak is a trap… but also an opportunity. Here's what's changing.

Peak used to mean pressure. Now it means unpredictability.

  • Traffic surges are the easy part. It's inconsistent data, untested integrations, and sprawling microservices that will break you.
  • Loyalty is low. Tolerance is lower. One slip and your customers won't come back.
  • New tech is being bolted on (AI, loyalty engines, MACH services) without foundational QA.
  • Most retailers are still betting on last year's data. But last year's success doesn't mean this year's stack is stable.

Questions retail tech leaders must ask (but often don't)

Let's get brutally honest. If you can't answer these, your peak is already in danger:

  • What part of your stack will fail first, and who's on the hook when it does? (Remember, it's not your tech provider's lost sale, it's yours.)
  • Have you validated new systems under actual peak-like traffic, or are you crossing your fingers?
  • What's changed in your environment since last peak, and have you retested those flows?
  • Are your third-party integrations, APIs, and loyalty tools tested at scale, or just "assumed fine"?
  • If the rollback plan had to happen tonight, could you execute it in under 30 minutes?

The hidden gaps that are hard to spot (until it's too late)

Spike's transformation work reveals the same blind spots in almost every pre-peak audit. Here are the five most critical:

From paranoia to preparedness: your peak survival protocol

Feeling uneasy? Good. That's your instincts telling you to act.

But knowing something's off isn't the same as preparing for it. You need a framework to de-risk before it's too late. Here is our 3-step peak survival protocol:

The clock is already ticking

Paranoia only becomes leadership when you act on it. Most retailers won't prepare until it's too late. You don't need another SI and you don't need another dashboard. You just need to harness your paranoia and turn it into action.